Protos

Free printable study guide

1 Samuel Bible study guide

A 1 Samuel Bible study that follows the story from Hannah's prayer at Shiloh to Saul's death on Mount Gilboa. Twelve sessions, each with questions tied to the verses and notes for the leader.

12 sessions · Personal study or small groups · No signup required

Illustration for the book of 1 Samuel

Book overview

Introduction to 1 Samuel

1 Samuel tells how Israel moved from judges to kings, and it asks what kind of king God's people need. A barren woman's prayer brings Samuel, who speaks the LORD's word to a nation that had stopped hearing it. The people ask for a king like the other nations have, and God gives them Saul, who looks the part and does not obey. God then chooses David, the youngest son, and David waits for the throne instead of taking it. Hannah's prayer states the theme at the start: the LORD humbles and exalts, and he will exalt the horn of his anointed (2:7-10).

12 study sessions

Start with session 1
Historical background
1 and 2 Samuel were originally one book. The story runs from the last days of the judges to the death of Saul; the Tyndale notes date the events to around 1050 to 1011 BC. The book is named for Samuel, not written by him, since his death is recorded at 25:1, and its final editor is never named. Tyndale's notes say it "could have been near its final form during or shortly after the reign of Solomon", while other scholars place its final shaping during or after the exile. The Hebrew text of Samuel has more difficulties than most Old Testament books, and the Greek and Dead Sea Scroll texts often differ from it. The BSB footnotes record many of these differences.
Literary context
Read 1 Samuel as a story told by a narrator who seldom stops to comment. When he does ("the LORD was with him", 3:19; 18:14), take note, because those lines tell you how to weigh what you see. Much is reported without approval: David lies (21:2; 27:10) and Saul consults a medium (28:7), and the narrator lets the results speak. Follow the pairs the book sets side by side: Hannah and Peninnah, Samuel and Eli's sons, Saul and Jonathan, Saul and David.

The shape of 1 Samuel

1 Samuel moves in six parts. The outline follows the movements traced in the Tyndale Open Study Notes: Samuel's rise (chapters 1 to 7), Israel's move to a monarchy (8:1-12:25), Saul's fall (13:1-15:35), and David's rise as Saul declines (chapters 16 to 31).

  1. 1 Samuel 1:1-3:21

    Samuel born and called

    Hannah prays for a son and gives him to the LORD. While Eli's sons corrupt the priesthood at Shiloh, the boy Samuel hears the LORD's voice and becomes a prophet all Israel recognizes.

  2. 1 Samuel 4:1-7:17

    The ark and Samuel's leadership

    Israel takes the ark into battle and loses it. The ark humbles Dagon and afflicts the Philistines until they send it back. Twenty years later Samuel calls Israel to return to the LORD, and the LORD defeats the Philistines at Mizpah.

  3. 1 Samuel 8:1-12:25

    Israel asks for a king

    The elders ask for a king like the other nations. Samuel warns them, the LORD grants the request, and Saul is anointed, chosen by lot and confirmed after a victory. Samuel's farewell sets the terms: fear the LORD, king and people alike.

  4. 1 Samuel 13:1-15:35

    Saul rejected

    Saul offers a sacrifice without waiting for Samuel, makes a rash oath that nearly costs Jonathan his life, and spares what the LORD told him to destroy. The LORD rejects him as king.

  5. 1 Samuel 16:1-20:42

    David anointed and in Saul's court

    Samuel anoints David in secret. David serves Saul, kills Goliath and wins Israel's love. Saul's jealousy turns to murderous intent, and Jonathan and Michal protect David.

  6. 1 Samuel 21:1-31:13

    David the fugitive, and Saul's end

    David flees, gathers a band of outcasts and twice refuses to kill Saul. He takes refuge with the Philistines. Saul consults a medium at Endor and dies with his sons on Mount Gilboa.

Bible study · 12 sessions

1 Samuel Study Questions

Each session covers one section of 1 Samuel. Read the passage aloud, then work through the questions in order. The verses after each question show where to look. Notes for the leader follow each session.

Jump to a session
  1. Session 1. 1 Samuel 1:1-2:11 · 39 verses

    Hannah's prayer

    Hannah, childless and taunted by her rival, pours out her soul to the LORD at Shiloh and promises to give him the son she asks for. The LORD answers, she keeps her vow, and she sings of the God who turns things upside down.

    1At that time Hannah prayed: “My heart rejoices in the LORD in whom my horn is exalted. My mouth speaks boldly against my enemies, for I rejoice in Your salvation. 2There is no one holy like the LORD. Indeed, there is no one besides You! And there is no Rock like our God.

    1 Samuel 2:1-2 (BSB)

    Key terms: Hannah, Elkanah, Eli, Shiloh, Vow, Horn

    Observe What does the text say?

    1. What do we learn about Elkanah's household in 1:1-8? What does Peninnah do, and how does Hannah respond (1:6-7)?1:1-8
    2. What does Hannah ask for and promise in 1:11? How does Eli misread her (1:12-14), and how does she answer him (1:15-16)?1:9-18
    3. Read Hannah's prayer aloud. List the reversals in 2:4-8: who is brought down, and who is lifted up?2:1-10

    Interpret What did it mean then?

    1. What does 1:19-20 give as the reason for Samuel's birth? The BSB footnote says his name sounds like "heard of God". How does the name fit the story?1:19-20
    2. Why might Hannah keep a vow that cost her her son? What does Elkanah do in 1:23?1:21-28
    3. Hannah ends by speaking of "His king" and "His anointed" (2:10), though Israel had no king yet. Why might the book open with these words?2:10

    Apply What does it mean for us?

    1. Hannah says she has "poured out my soul before the LORD" (1:15). What would it look like for you to pray that honestly?1:10-16
    2. Hannah says the LORD humbles and exalts. Where does that warn you, and where does it comfort you?2:3-8
    For the leader
    What to look for
    The story starts with a family, not a nation. The narrator says twice that the LORD had closed Hannah's womb (1:5-6), so the birth of Samuel is framed as God's doing. Follow the word asked through the chapter (1:17, 20, 27-28).
    Explaining the passage
    Tyndale's notes say Hannah's prayer celebrates God's uniqueness, "his ability to reverse fortunes (2:3-9), and his ability to strengthen his chosen king (2:10)", and compare it with Mary's song in Luke 1:46-55 (on 2:1-10). On 1:11: "Hannah’s vow was a promise to give the child back to the Lord as a Nazirite". The BSB footnote on 1:22 records that the Dead Sea Scrolls add "I will offer him as a Nazirite for all time".
    Where readers differ
    Readers hear 2:10 at more than one level. In its setting it looks ahead to Israel's kings, and above all to David. Christians also read it as pointing to Christ, and Tyndale's notes call the verse "prophetic both of Israel’s anointed kings and of God’s supreme Anointed King" (on 2:10).
    Keeping the application bounded
    Some in the group may carry infertility, miscarriage or a long unanswered prayer. The text tells what God did for Hannah. It does not promise every woman who prays the same answer, so do not promise it. Keep the application on honest prayer, and on the cruelty of Peninnah, which the narrator plainly condemns.
  2. Session 2. 1 Samuel 2:12-3:21 · 46 verses

    Eli's sons and the boy who listened

    Eli's sons treat the LORD's offerings with contempt and abuse their office, and Eli does not restrain them. Meanwhile the boy Samuel grows up in the LORD's presence. In a time when the word of the LORD was rare, the LORD calls Samuel by name.

    9“Go and lie down,” he said to Samuel, “and if He calls you, say, ‘Speak, LORD, for Your servant is listening.’” So Samuel went and lay down in his place. 10Then the LORD came and stood there, calling as before, “Samuel! Samuel!” And Samuel answered, “Speak, for Your servant is listening.”

    1 Samuel 3:9-10 (BSB)

    Key terms: Eli, Phinehas, Samuel, Shiloh, Prophet

    Observe What does the text say?

    1. What exactly were Eli's sons doing with the sacrifices (2:13-16)? How does the narrator judge it in 2:12 and 2:17?2:12-17
    2. The narrator moves back and forth between Eli's sons and the boy Samuel (2:18-21, 26). What is said about Samuel each time?2:18-26
    3. Why did Samuel not recognize the LORD's voice (3:7)? Who finally understood what was happening (3:8-9)?3:1-10

    Interpret What did it mean then?

    1. How does Eli respond to what his sons are doing (2:23-25)? Compare what the LORD says Eli failed to do in 3:13.2:22-25
    2. What does the man of God say Eli has done (2:29)? What does "I will honor those who honor Me" (2:30) mean in this setting?2:27-36
    3. How does Eli respond to the message of judgment in 3:18? Is it faith, resignation, or both?3:11-18

    Apply What does it mean for us?

    1. "Speak, for Your servant is listening" (3:10). What helps you listen to God, and what gets in the way?3:9-10
    2. Samuel had to tell a hard truth to the man who raised him. When have you needed to say something hard to someone above you, and how did you go about it?3:15-18
    For the leader
    What to look for
    The narrator sets the corrupt priests and the faithful boy side by side, back and forth. The section moves from silence to speech: "the word of the LORD was rare" (3:1), and by the end the LORD revealed himself to Samuel "by His word" (3:21).
    Explaining the passage
    Tyndale's notes say Eli's sons "did not acknowledge God or seek to abide by his will" (on 2:12), and on 3:13: "Eli rebuked his sons (2:23-25), but he did not restrain them." In 3:13 the BSB follows the Greek; its footnote gives the Hebrew as "made themselves contemptible".
    Where readers differ
    Verse 2:25 says the sons would not listen "since the LORD intended to put them to death". Tyndale's notes read this as judgment already under way: "the Lord had already begun to punish them by hardening their hearts". Other readers stress that the sons had refused God for a long time before this, so the judgment answers their own choices. Both readings hold the sons responsible.
    Keeping the application bounded
    Be careful with Eli. The text holds him responsible for not restraining adult sons who were priests abusing their office, including sexual abuse of the women who served at the tent (2:22). It is not a verdict on every parent whose child walks away from faith. Keep the application on leaders who protect wrongdoers, and on listening to God.
  3. Session 3. 1 Samuel 4:1-7:17 · 72 verses

    The ark taken and returned

    Israel carries the ark into battle as if it guaranteed victory, and loses both the battle and the ark. In Philistine hands the ark humbles Dagon and brings affliction until it is sent home. Twenty years later Samuel calls the people back to the LORD, and the LORD routs the Philistines.

    12Afterward, Samuel took a stone and set it up between Mizpah and Shen. He named it Ebenezer, saying, “Thus far the LORD has helped us.”

    1 Samuel 7:12 (BSB)

    Key terms: Ark, Philistines, Dagon, Ashdod, Mizpah

    Observe What does the text say?

    1. Why did the elders bring the ark into battle (4:3)? What happened (4:10-11)?4:1-11
    2. How did Eli and his daughter-in-law react to the news? What does the name Ichabod mean (4:21-22)?4:12-22
    3. What happened to Dagon in 5:1-5, and to the Philistine cities in 5:6-12?5:1-12

    Interpret What did it mean then?

    1. Both Israel and the Philistines treat the ark as a source of power (4:3, 7-8). What were they getting wrong about God?4:3-9
    2. How did the Philistines test whether the LORD had struck them (6:7-9)? What does the result show?6:1-12
    3. Why were men of Beth-shemesh struck down (6:19)? What questions do they ask in 6:20?6:19-7:2
    4. What changed between the defeat in chapter 4 and the victory in chapter 7 (7:3-6)? Who fought the battle (7:10)?7:3-14

    Apply What does it mean for us?

    1. Where are you tempted to treat something holy, such as a ritual, a building or a habit of prayer, as a guarantee that God will do what you want?4:3
    2. "Thus far the LORD has helped us." What could serve as your stone of help, a way to remember a time God helped you?7:12
    For the leader
    What to look for
    Samuel drops out of the story from 4:1 to 7:2; the ark is the main character. Tyndale's introduction notes that Samuel "is absent from that narrative". The name Ebenezer appears at the defeat (4:1) and again at the victory (7:12).
    Explaining the passage
    Tyndale's notes on 4:3: "the Israelites treated the Ark, the most sacred symbol of the Lord’s presence, as a charm to ward off misfortune." On 7:3-10: "The change in the people’s standing with God, not the presence of the Ark (see 4:3-11), led Israel to victory". Dagon's broken head and hands are "A symbol of God’s supremacy over the idol" (on 5:4).
    Where readers differ
    The number struck down at Beth-shemesh differs among manuscripts. The BSB reads seventy men, and its footnote says most Hebrew manuscripts have 70 men and 50,000 men. Readers also differ on what the tumors of 5:6 were; Tyndale's notes suggest bubonic plague as one possibility (on 5:6).
    Keeping the application bounded
    The deaths at Beth-shemesh are hard, and the group may say so. The narrator's point is God's holiness, and the people's question in 6:20 is a fair one to ask honestly. Avoid turning the story into a promise that God always intervenes for us against our enemies; in chapter 4 he did not.
  4. Session 4. 1 Samuel 8:1-22 · 22 verses

    Give us a king

    Samuel is old and his sons are corrupt, so the elders ask for a king to judge them like all the other nations. The LORD tells Samuel the people have rejected God as their king, has him warn them what a king will take, and then grants their request.

    7And the LORD said to Samuel, “Listen to the voice of the people in all that they say to you. For it is not you they have rejected, but they have rejected Me as their king.

    1 Samuel 8:7 (BSB)

    Key terms: Samuel, Kingdom, Justice

    Observe What does the text say?

    1. What two reasons do the elders give for wanting a king (8:5)? Compare Samuel's sons in 8:3 with Eli's sons in 2:12.8:1-5
    2. How does Samuel take the request (8:6), and what does the LORD tell him (8:7-9)?8:6-9
    3. Count how many things the king will take in 8:11-17. What will he take?8:10-18

    Interpret What did it mean then?

    1. The LORD says "they have rejected Me as their king" (8:7). How can asking for a human king be a rejection of God, when Deuteronomy 17:14-20 allows for one? See the readings section.8:7-8
    2. What do the people want a king to do (8:20)? What does wanting to be "like all the other nations" reveal?8:19-20
    3. Why might God give them what they asked for, knowing what it would cost them?8:21-22

    Apply What does it mean for us?

    1. Where do you want to be like everyone else, even after you have been warned what it will cost?8:19-20
    2. Samuel takes his hurt to the LORD in prayer (8:6). What do you do when people reject you?8:6
    For the leader
    What to look for
    Most of the chapter is speech. The elders ask, the LORD answers Samuel, Samuel warns, the people insist, and the LORD gives way. The verb take runs through Samuel's warning.
    Explaining the passage
    Tyndale's notes on 8:10-18: "Each sentence begins with something the king would take. A king would be a confiscator, not just a protector." On 8:11: "They wanted a leader but received a ruler." On 8:8 they call Israel's monarchy "a divine concession rather than a divine gift".
    Where readers differ
    Readers differ on whether asking for a king was wrong in itself, or whether the fault lay in the motive and the timing. The readings section sets out the views.
    Keeping the application bounded
    Do not read this chapter as a verdict on any modern system of government. Its concern is trust: whether Israel would rely on the LORD, who had been their king, or on a ruler like the other nations had.
  5. Session 5. 1 Samuel 9:1-12:25 · 94 verses

    Saul made king

    A search for lost donkeys brings Saul to Samuel, who anoints him in private. Saul is chosen by lot at Mizpah, proves himself by rescuing Jabesh-gilead, and is confirmed at Gilgal. Samuel gives his farewell: the people sinned in asking for a king, but if king and people fear the LORD, all will be well.

    23As for me, far be it from me that I should sin against the LORD by ceasing to pray for you. And I will continue to teach you the good and right way. 24Above all, fear the LORD and serve Him faithfully with all your heart; consider what great things He has done for you.

    1 Samuel 12:23-24 (BSB)

    Key terms: Saul, Kish, Anoint, Gilgal, Jabesh, Ramah

    Observe What does the text say?

    1. How does the story of the lost donkeys bring Saul to Samuel? What does the LORD tell Samuel in 9:16-17?9:1-17
    2. What signs did Samuel give Saul (10:2-6)? What happened to Saul in 10:9-10?10:1-13
    3. What threat did Jabesh-gilead face, and how did Saul respond (11:6-11)? How did he treat those who had despised him (11:12-13)?11:1-15

    Interpret What did it mean then?

    1. Saul calls his clan the least (9:21) and later hides among the baggage (10:22). Is this humility, fear, or something else? Does the narrator say?9:21-10:27
    2. At Mizpah Samuel says "today you have rejected your God" (10:19), in the same gathering that makes Saul king. How do both things stand together?10:17-27
    3. Samuel puts himself on trial (12:3-5) and then reviews Israel's history (12:6-12). What condition does he set for the king and the people (12:14-15)?12:1-15
    4. What does Samuel promise to keep doing (12:23)? What is "the good and right way" he will teach?12:19-25

    Apply What does it mean for us?

    1. Samuel says, "Even though you have committed all this evil, do not turn aside" (12:20). How does that speak to you after a choice you regret?12:20-22
    2. "consider what great things He has done for you" (12:24). Name one with the group.12:24
    For the leader
    What to look for
    Saul becomes king in three steps: anointed in private (9:1-10:16), chosen by lot in public (10:17-27), and confirmed after a victory (11:1-15). Samuel's farewell in chapter 12 sets the terms for the new arrangement.
    Explaining the passage
    Tyndale's notes: "Saul’s rise to power involved a threefold sequence" (on 9:1-11:15). On 10:9, "God gave Saul courage and strength, helping him overcome his hesitancy". On 12:6-25: "In 12:1-5, Samuel put himself on trial and was found innocent. In 12:6-25, he put the nation on trial and found it guilty." The BSB footnote on 10:27 records a paragraph about Nahash found in one Dead Sea Scroll manuscript.
    Where readers differ
    Readers differ on Saul's early reluctance (9:21; 10:16, 22). Some see real humility. Others see a fearfulness that returns later (15:24). Tyndale's notes suggest his silence in 10:16 may come from "lingering uncertainty about what had transpired". The narrator does not say.
    Keeping the application bounded
    Give time to 12:20-25. Samuel does not tell the people their mistake can be undone; the king stays. He tells them to serve the LORD from where they are, and he promises to keep praying for them.
  6. Session 6. 1 Samuel 13:1-14:52 · 75 verses

    Saul's offering and Jonathan's faith

    Facing a huge Philistine army and deserting troops, Saul offers the sacrifice himself instead of waiting for Samuel, and Samuel says his kingdom will not endure. Jonathan attacks a Philistine outpost trusting the LORD, while Saul's rash oath weakens the army and nearly costs Jonathan his life.

    6Jonathan said to the young man bearing his armor, “Come, let us cross over to the outpost of these uncircumcised men. Perhaps the LORD will work on our behalf. Nothing can hinder the LORD from saving, whether by many or by few.”

    1 Samuel 14:6 (BSB)

    Key terms: Jonathan, Michmash, Gilgal, Urim, Thummim

    Observe What does the text say?

    1. What situation did Saul face at Gilgal (13:5-8), and what did he do (13:9)?13:5-9
    2. What reasons does Saul give (13:11-12)? What does Samuel say will happen (13:13-14)?13:10-14
    3. What does Jonathan say before he attacks (14:6)? How does the battle turn (14:15)?14:1-15

    Interpret What did it mean then?

    1. Why is this such a serious failure? Read the leader note on which command Saul broke.13:13-14
    2. What oath did Saul make (14:24), and what did it cost his troops (14:29-32)?14:24-32
    3. Saul is ready to execute his own son (14:39, 44). Who stops him, and on what grounds (14:45)?14:36-46

    Apply What does it mean for us?

    1. Saul says he "felt compelled" (13:12). When does pressure push you to do the wrong thing for reasons that seem good at the time?13:11-12
    2. "Nothing can hinder the LORD from saving, whether by many or by few." Where do you need that kind of trust, without assuming the outcome is guaranteed?14:6
    For the leader
    What to look for
    Saul and Jonathan are set side by side. Saul stays in camp (14:2) and then binds the army with a rash oath; Jonathan acts in faith without telling his father (14:1). The summary in 14:47-52 also records Saul's real military successes.
    Explaining the passage
    Tyndale's notes point out that "Other kings offered sacrifices without censure" (on 13:13), so the fault was disobeying the order Samuel had given. They think the order "most likely was not the instruction in 10:8 but an unrecorded instruction" (on 13:8); that is a reconstruction. On 14:23: "It was God, not Saul, who saved Israel". The Hebrew of 13:1 is damaged, as the BSB footnotes show.
    Where readers differ
    Readers locate the fault in 13:8-14 differently. Some stress that a king took a priest's role. Others, with Tyndale's notes, stress that Saul disobeyed the prophet's word. Others see impatience that revealed distrust of God. Many see all three, and some find the penalty severe for one offering until they read chapter 15.
    Keeping the application bounded
    Do not turn Jonathan into a formula: act boldly and God will bless. His "Perhaps" (14:6) is the point. He trusted God without presuming on him.
  7. Session 7. 1 Samuel 15:1-35 · 35 verses

    To obey is better than sacrifice

    The LORD commands Saul to destroy the Amalekites completely. Saul spares King Agag and the best of the livestock, claims he obeyed, and blames the troops. Samuel tells him that obedience is better than sacrifice, and that the LORD has rejected him as king.

    22But Samuel declared: “Does the LORD delight in burnt offerings and sacrifices as much as in obedience to His voice? Behold, obedience is better than sacrifice, and attentiveness is better than the fat of rams. 23For rebellion is like the sin of divination, and arrogance is like the wickedness of idolatry. Because you have rejected the word of the LORD, He has rejected you as king.”

    1 Samuel 15:22-23 (BSB)

    Key terms: Amalekites, Agag, Sacrifice, Repentance, Gilgal

    Observe What does the text say?

    1. What did the LORD command (15:2-3), and what did Saul and the army actually do (15:9)?15:1-9
    2. Trace Saul's answers to Samuel in 15:13, 15 and 20-21. Who does he say did what?15:10-21
    3. What does Saul confess, and what does he ask for (15:24-25, 30)?15:24-31

    Interpret What did it mean then?

    1. The command to "devote to destruction" (15:3) is one of the hardest texts in Scripture. What reason does the text give for it (15:2)? Read the readings section.15:2-3
    2. What does Samuel mean by "obedience is better than sacrifice"? Why compare rebellion with divination?15:22-23
    3. The LORD "regretted" making Saul king (15:11, 35), yet 15:29 says he does not "change His mind". How do these fit together? See the readings section.15:10-35

    Apply What does it mean for us?

    1. Saul calls partial obedience obedience. Where do you do the same?15:13-21
    2. "I feared the people and obeyed their voice." Whose approval most shapes your choices?15:24
    For the leader
    What to look for
    Saul never quite owns his fault. He blames the troops (15:15, 21), then says he feared the people (15:24), and asks Samuel to honor him before the elders (15:30). Samuel cries out to the LORD all night (15:11) and mourns Saul afterward (15:35).
    Explaining the passage
    Tyndale's notes on 15:2 say the Amalekites "preyed on the sick and the weak and those traveling at the rear" and were "the first people to attack Israel after the exodus from Egypt" (Exodus 17:8-16; Deuteronomy 25:17-19). The BSB footnote on 15:3 explains the Hebrew cherem as "the giving over of things or persons to the LORD, either by destroying them or by giving them as an offering". On 15:22: "God values obedience much more than ritual".
    Where readers differ
    Christians read the command in 15:3 in several ways, set out in the readings section. Amalekites appear again later (27:8; 30:1). Some take that as evidence that total-destruction language is a form of ancient war rhetoric; others take it as a sign of how incomplete the campaign was.
    Keeping the application bounded
    Say plainly what the text describes: an order to kill a whole people, children included, and Samuel's execution of Agag (15:33). Do not soften it into something else, and do not let anyone treat it as a pattern for violence today. Let people voice their discomfort. The point Samuel presses on Saul is obedience to God's word, and the application belongs there.
  8. Session 8. 1 Samuel 16:1-23 · 23 verses

    The LORD looks at the heart

    The LORD sends Samuel to Bethlehem to anoint one of Jesse's sons. Samuel is drawn to the tall firstborn, but the LORD chooses the youngest, who was out with the sheep. The Spirit of the LORD comes on David and leaves Saul, and David enters Saul's service as a musician.

    7But the LORD said to Samuel, “Do not consider his appearance or height, for I have rejected him; the LORD does not see as man does. For man sees the outward appearance, but the LORD sees the heart.”

    1 Samuel 16:7 (BSB)

    Key terms: David, Jesse, Bethlehem, Anoint, Horn

    Observe What does the text say?

    1. Why was Samuel afraid (16:2), and what did the LORD tell him to do?16:1-5
    2. Why did Samuel think Eliab was the one (16:6)? How many sons passed before David was sent for?16:6-13
    3. What happened to Saul after the Spirit of the LORD left him (16:14)? How did David come into Saul's service?16:14-23

    Interpret What did it mean then?

    1. "man sees the outward appearance, but the LORD sees the heart." Compare Saul's description in 9:2. Why does the narrator describe David's looks in 16:12, right after this?16:7
    2. Read 16:13 and 16:14 together. What is the narrator setting side by side?16:13-14
    3. What is the "spirit of distress from the LORD" (16:14)? Read the readings section.16:14-16

    Apply What does it mean for us?

    1. Whom do you tend to judge by appearance? How might God see them differently?16:7
    2. David served the king who would later hunt him. Where can you serve someone well while your own future is uncertain?16:21-23
    For the leader
    What to look for
    The youngest son, not even called to the sacrifice (16:11), is the one chosen. Saul and David have much in common: both are anointed by Samuel, both are described as good-looking (9:2; 16:12), and the Spirit comes on both (10:10; 16:13).
    Explaining the passage
    Tyndale's notes on 16:13: "The Spirit of the Lord had also come upon Saul (10:10) but had left him because of disobedience (16:14)." The BSB footnote on 16:14 gives "Or a harmful spirit".
    Where readers differ
    Readers discuss whether the LORD's instruction in 16:2, to say he had come to sacrifice, was a deception. Many note that Samuel did offer the sacrifice (16:5), so what he said was true, though not the whole truth. Others see a concealment the text allows because Saul's threat was real.
    Keeping the application bounded
    Verse 7 is often used to tell people their looks do not matter. That is fair, but the verse is first about how God chooses a leader. Ask the group what they look for in leaders, and whether it is what God looks for.
  9. Session 9. 1 Samuel 17:1-58 · 58 verses

    The battle is the LORD's

    Goliath of Gath defies Israel for forty days, and Saul and his army are afraid. David, sent with food for his brothers, takes the defiance as an insult to the living God, refuses Saul's armor, and kills Goliath with a sling and a stone so that all will know the battle is the LORD's.

    45But David said to the Philistine, “You come against me with sword and spear and javelin, but I come against you in the name of the LORD of Hosts, the God of the armies of Israel, whom you have defied. 46This day the LORD will deliver you into my hand. This day I will strike you down, cut off your head, and give the carcasses of the Philistines to the birds of the air and the creatures of the earth. Then the whole world will know that there is a God in Israel. 47And all those assembled here will know that it is not by sword or spear that the LORD saves; for the battle is the LORD’s, and He will give all of you into our hands.”

    1 Samuel 17:45-47 (BSB)

    Key terms: Goliath, Gath, Philistines, Abner, Jesse

    Observe What does the text say?

    1. Describe Goliath and his challenge (17:4-10). How did Saul and Israel respond (17:11)?17:1-11
    2. What questions does David ask (17:26)? How does Eliab respond (17:28)?17:26-30
    3. What does David refuse, and what does he take instead (17:38-40)? How does the fight end (17:49-50)?17:38-50

    Interpret What did it mean then?

    1. What reasons does David give Saul for thinking he can fight (17:34-37)? Whom does he credit?17:34-37
    2. What does David say the battle will show "the whole world" and "all those assembled here" (17:46-47)?17:45-47
    3. Saul asks whose son David is (17:55), though David had served him in chapter 16. Read the leader note. How do you account for it?17:55-58

    Apply What does it mean for us?

    1. The story is often told as a lesson in beating your giants. What does David say this victory was for (17:46-47)? How does that change the way you apply it?17:45-47
    2. David is dismissed by his brother and by the king. When have you been underestimated, or underestimated someone else?17:28-33
    For the leader
    What to look for
    The narrator gives far more space to the speeches (17:26-37, 43-47) than to the fight (17:48-51). David's words keep returning to God: the living God (17:26) and the LORD of Hosts (17:45).
    Explaining the passage
    Tyndale's notes explain the champion: "rival forces would sometimes agree to let selected individuals from each side decide a conflict" (on 17:4). The BSB footnote on 17:4 says Goliath "was approximately 9 feet 9 inches or 297 centimeters tall" by the Hebrew text, while the Greek, a Dead Sea Scroll and Josephus give "four cubits and a span", about six feet nine.
    Where readers differ
    Readers explain 17:55-58 in several ways. Tyndale's notes suggest David served Saul only part of the time (on 17:15) or that the events of chapter 17 came before or long after that service (on 17:55-58). Some think Saul was asking about David's family, since he had promised his daughter to the man who killed Goliath (17:25). Others think two accounts of David's arrival have been placed side by side; the main Greek text lacks several parts of chapters 17 and 18, including 17:55-58.
    Keeping the application bounded
    Keep the focus where David puts it: the LORD saves, and not by sword or spear (17:47). The promise that every believer will defeat every giant goes beyond the text. David's concern is God's name, not his own success.
  10. Session 10. 1 Samuel 18:1-20:42 · 96 verses

    Saul's jealousy, Jonathan's loyalty

    Jonathan makes a covenant with David and gives him his robe and weapons. A victory song turns Saul's fear into jealousy, and he tries again and again to kill David. Jonathan and Michal each protect David from their father, and Jonathan and David part in tears, bound by an oath in the LORD's name.

    3Then Jonathan made a covenant with David because he loved him as himself. 4And Jonathan removed the robe he was wearing and gave it to David, along with his tunic, his sword, his bow, and his belt.

    1 Samuel 18:3-4 (BSB)

    Key terms: Jonathan, Michal, Saul, Covenant, Friend

    Observe What does the text say?

    1. What did Jonathan do in 18:3-4? What might the robe and weapons signify?18:1-5
    2. What song did the women sing (18:7)? How did Saul react (18:8-9, 12)?18:6-16
    3. How did Jonathan and Michal each protect David from their father (19:4-7, 11-17)?19:1-17

    Interpret What did it mean then?

    1. The narrator repeats that "the LORD was with" David (18:12, 14, 28). Why does that matter for how we read Saul's fear?18:12-16
    2. What happened when Saul came to Ramah (19:23-24)? Compare 10:10-12. What does the saying "Is Saul also among the prophets?" mean now?19:18-24
    3. What does Jonathan ask David to promise (20:14-15)? The BSB calls it "loving devotion", Hebrew chesed. Why does this word matter in the friendship?20:12-17

    Apply What does it mean for us?

    1. Jonathan stood with David at great cost to himself. What would it cost you to stand with someone whom people in power are against?20:30-34
    2. Saul's jealousy began with a song. What feeds envy in you, and what helps you name it early?18:8-9
    For the leader
    What to look for
    Almost everyone in these chapters loves David: Jonathan (18:1), all Israel and Judah (18:16), Michal (18:20). Saul alone grows "even more afraid" (18:29), because he sees that the LORD is with David (18:28).
    Explaining the passage
    Tyndale's notes on 18:3-4: "By giving David items that symbolized his official status as the king’s son and crown prince, Jonathan symbolically gave David his right of succession to the throne." The BSB footnote on 20:14 gives the range of chesed: "love, goodness, kindness, faithfulness, and mercy, as well as loyalty to a covenant".
    Where readers differ
    Most readers take the bond of David and Jonathan as a covenant friendship, and its language (covenant, oath, loving devotion) as the language of loyalty between allies. Some modern interpreters read it as romantic or sexual. Tyndale's notes reject that reading and say "the text implies nothing other than a deep and loyal friendship" (on 18:1).
    Keeping the application bounded
    Saul's spear (18:11; 19:10; 20:33) is violence inside a household. If someone in the group lives with violence at home, the lesson is not to stay and endure it. David fled, and Jonathan and Michal helped him escape. Help that person toward safety.
  11. Session 11. 1 Samuel 21:1-26:25 · 158 verses

    David will not seize the throne

    David flees, deceives the priest at Nob, and gathers a band of the distressed and indebted. Saul massacres the priests. Twice David has Saul in his power and refuses to kill the LORD's anointed, and in between Abigail stops him from taking revenge on Nabal.

    6So he said to his men, “The LORD forbid that I should do such a thing to my master, the LORD’s anointed. May I never lift my hand against him, since he is the LORD’s anointed.”

    1 Samuel 24:6 (BSB)

    Key terms: Ahimelech, Nob, Doeg, Achish, Keilah, Nabal

    Observe What does the text say?

    1. What did David tell Ahimelech (21:2), and what did he receive (21:6, 9)?21:1-9
    2. What did Saul do to the priests of Nob (22:17-19)? What did David say to Abiathar (22:22)?22:6-23
    3. What did David's men urge in the cave (24:4)? What did David do, and why did his conscience trouble him (24:5-6)?24:1-7

    Interpret What did it mean then?

    1. The narrator does not comment on David's lie to Ahimelech (21:2). How does 22:22 show what it cost?22:22
    2. What does Abigail say David is about to do (25:26, 31)? How does David answer her (25:32-33)?25:23-35
    3. In chapter 26 David spares Saul a second time. What reasons does he give (26:9-11)? How does his reading of events differ from his men's (24:4; 26:8)?26:7-12

    Apply What does it mean for us?

    1. Who has been an Abigail to you, stopping you before you did something you would regret? Could you be one for someone else?25:32-33
    2. "May the LORD judge between you and me" (24:12). Where do you need to leave justice with God instead of taking it yourself?24:12
    For the leader
    What to look for
    Chapters 24 to 26 form a set: David spares Saul (24), is kept from killing Nabal (25), and spares Saul again (26). Tyndale's notes: "This episode about Nabal falls between two accounts in which Saul pursued David and David spared Saul’s life. Nabal was similar to Saul." The BSB footnote on 25:25 says "Nabal means fool".
    Explaining the passage
    Tyndale's notes say plainly that "David lied to conceal his outlaw status" (on 21:2). On 24:4 they say David's men assumed that "if the circumstances seem right, the Lord is telling you through those circumstances what to do". David refuses that logic twice. Jonathan's last visit (23:16-18) is a quiet center: he strengthened David's hand in God.
    Where readers differ
    Readers weigh David's conduct in these chapters differently. Many read them as showing his integrity and trust in God. Others notice the narrator's silence on his lies (21:2) and his oath to wipe out Nabal's men (25:21-22), and read him more critically. The text supports both, which is part of how it tells the story. Jesus later cites the episode of the consecrated bread (21:6) in Mark 2:25-26.
    Keeping the application bounded
    Do not use "the LORD's anointed" (24:6; 26:9) to shield church leaders from accountability. David's restraint was about killing the king. He still fled, confronted Saul openly (24:9-15) and left judgment to God. A leader who harms people should be reported to those who can act.
  12. Session 12. 1 Samuel 27:1-31:13 · 92 verses

    Saul's last night

    David takes refuge with the Philistines and deceives their king. Facing the Philistine army, and with no answer from the LORD, Saul consults a medium at Endor and hears his doom. David, in distress at Ziklag, finds strength in the LORD and recovers everything. Saul and his sons die on Mount Gilboa.

    6And David was greatly distressed because the people spoke of stoning him, because the soul of every man grieved for his sons and daughters. But David found strength in the LORD his God.

    1 Samuel 30:6 (BSB)

    Key terms: Achish, Ziklag, Gilboa, Jabesh, Amalekites, Saul

    Observe What does the text say?

    1. Why did David go to the Philistines (27:1)? What did he tell Achish about his raids, and what did he actually do (27:8-11)?27:1-12
    2. What had Saul done to mediums earlier (28:3)? What happened when he inquired of the LORD (28:6), and what did he do next?28:3-7
    3. How did Saul die (31:3-6)? Who honored his body, and why might they have done it (31:11-13; compare 11:1-11)?31:1-13

    Interpret What did it mean then?

    1. What did the woman see (28:12-14), and what did Samuel say (28:16-19)? Read the readings section on what appeared.28:11-19
    2. Compare Saul in 28:5-7 with David in 30:6-8. What does each do in distress?30:1-8
    3. What rule did David make about the plunder (30:24), and why (30:23)?30:21-25

    Apply What does it mean for us?

    1. "David found strength in the LORD his God." What does that look like when people you trusted turn on you?30:6
    2. When God seems silent, where are you tempted to look for answers?28:5-7
    For the leader
    What to look for
    The narrator cuts between David in the south and Saul in the north. Tyndale's notes: "While David was in the south successfully fighting the Amalekites (ch 30), Saul was in the north unsuccessfully fighting the Philistines." The book ends with Saul buried by the town he once saved.
    Explaining the passage
    Tyndale's notes on 28:3-14: "Saul consulted the dead, a practice forbidden by God’s law". On 30:6 they set the two men side by side: "When “in deep trouble” (28:15), Saul turned to necromancy, with disastrous results. David, by contrast, found strength and success in the Lord his God." On David's raids: "The text does not commend David for lying to the foreign king, but neither does it condemn him" (on 27:10).
    Where readers differ
    Readers differ on what appeared at Endor: Samuel himself, a spirit imitating him, or a deception by the medium. The readings section sets out the views. The BSB footnote on 28:13 gives other renderings of what the woman saw: "Or I see a spirit or I see a divine being".
    Keeping the application bounded
    Saul takes his own life (31:4). Some in the group may have lost someone to suicide, so speak with care. The narrator records it without comment on Saul's eternal state, and the people of Jabesh honored him (31:11-13). If anyone is struggling, help them get support the same day. Notice too that the medium, of all people, shows Saul kindness (28:21-25).

Themes and interpretation

1 Samuel Themes and Interpretation

Key themes

  • The LORD who brings down the proud and lifts up the lowly (2:1-10)
  • Hearing the word of the LORD when it was rare (3:1-21)
  • God as Israel's king, and the human king Israel asked for (8:7; 12:12-25)
  • Obedience over ritual (13:13-14; 15:22-23)
  • The LORD looks at the heart (16:7)
  • Waiting for God instead of seizing power (24:6; 26:9-11)
  • Covenant loyalty: Jonathan's faithfulness to David (18:3; 20:14-17)

Interpretive considerations

  • Do not turn every character into a moral example. The narrator reports much that he does not approve, including some of David's lies and violence. Let the narrator's own comments and the way each episode turns out guide your judgment.
  • David and Goliath is about the LORD's name (17:45-47), not a technique for personal success. In the same way, God answered Hannah's prayer, but the text does not promise every prayer for a child the same answer.
  • Some passages are hard: the deaths at Beth-shemesh (6:19), the ban on Amalek (15:3), the medium at Endor (28:3-25) and Saul's death by his own hand (31:4). The readings section sets out how Christians read them. Name the difficulty instead of explaining it away.
  • Do not use "the LORD's anointed" (24:6) to shield leaders from accountability. David refused to kill the king, but he still fled from him and spoke openly about the wrong Saul had done (24:9-15).
  • Several numbers in the Hebrew text are uncertain (13:1; 17:4; 6:19). Check the BSB footnotes before building anything on one.

Additional resources: 1 Samuel commentary and Bible dictionary.

Interpretation

Where Christians read 1 Samuel differently

Faithful readers disagree on these questions. Each entry sets out the main views on their own terms. A group does not need to settle them to finish the study.

Was it wrong for Israel to ask for a king?

1 Samuel 8:4-22; 10:17-19; 12:12-25

The LORD tells Samuel "they have rejected Me as their king" (8:7), and the people later confess "the evil of asking for a king" (12:19). Yet Deuteronomy 17:14-20 makes room for a king, Hannah's prayer already looks for one (2:10), and God himself chooses Saul (9:16). Some readers conclude that the request itself rejected God's rule; Tyndale's notes call the monarchy "a divine concession rather than a divine gift" (on 8:8). Others think the fault lay in the motive and the timing: Israel wanted a king "like all the other nations" (8:5, 20) to save them, when the LORD was already their king (12:12). On that reading, God later gave a king of his own choosing in David. Many critical scholars think the book weaves together older accounts, some favoring kingship and some opposing it. Read as it stands, the book holds both: kingship is given, and the request that brought it is judged.

Does God change his mind?

1 Samuel 15:10-11; 15:29; 15:35

The LORD says "I regret that I have made Saul king" (15:11), and the chapter ends with "the LORD regretted that He had made Saul king" (15:35). Between them Samuel says God "does not lie or change His mind, for He is not a man" (15:29). Some read the regret as language suited to human understanding: God does not change, but Scripture describes his response to sin in human terms. Others hold that the regret is real, that God truly responds to what people do while his character and purposes stay fixed; on that reading 15:29 means God will not reverse his verdict on Saul. A few go further and take it to mean that God did not know in advance how Saul would turn out, a view most Christians reject. Every reading takes 15:29 to mean that Saul's rejection stood.

How should Christians read the command to destroy the Amalekites?

1 Samuel 15:1-35

The command in 15:3 includes "children and infants". The BSB footnote explains the Hebrew cherem as "the giving over of things or persons to the LORD, either by destroying them or by giving them as an offering". The text grounds the command in what Amalek did when Israel came out of Egypt (15:2; Exodus 17:8-16; Deuteronomy 25:17-19), and Tyndale's notes add that the Amalekites "preyed on the sick and the weak". Christians respond in several ways. Some hold that God, as judge of the nations, brought judgment through Israel in this one case, as Scripture says he did elsewhere through other nations, and that the command was unique, never a pattern. Some scholars argue that total-destruction language was a stock form of ancient Near Eastern war rhetoric, and note that Amalekites appear again soon after (27:8; 30:1). Others read the passage within a progressive revelation, in which Israel's grasp of God's will grew, and read it in light of Jesus' command to love enemies. Some find the command morally troubling on any reading and say so plainly. All of these readings agree that it gives no warrant for violence today.

What was the "spirit of distress from the LORD" that troubled Saul?

1 Samuel 16:14-23; 18:10; 19:9

The BSB footnote on 16:14 gives "Or a harmful spirit". Many readers, ancient and modern, take it as an evil spirit that God sent or permitted as judgment once his Spirit had left Saul (compare Judges 9:23 and 1 Kings 22:19-23). Tyndale's notes say it came "as a consequence of Saul’s disobedience" (on 16:14). Others take the phrase as the Old Testament's way of describing a dark mental and emotional affliction, attributed to God because he is Lord over all that happens. Many combine the two. The text makes two points without settling how it worked: the change in Saul followed the departure of the LORD's Spirit, and David's music brought him relief (16:23). It gives no basis for treating depression or mental illness as a sign of God's rejection.

What appeared at Endor?

1 Samuel 28:3-25

The narrator writes "when the woman saw Samuel" (28:12), and the figure speaks as Samuel and foretells what happens the next day (28:19; 31:6). Many take it that Samuel really appeared, by God's doing and not by the medium's power; her loud cry (28:12) suggests she did not expect it. Others hold that an evil spirit imitated Samuel, since God had refused to answer Saul (28:6) and the law forbids consulting the dead (Deuteronomy 18:10-12). A third view is that the medium staged it, though the narrator's wording makes that harder to hold. The woman says "I see a god coming up out of the earth" (28:13), and Tyndale's notes admit "It is not clear why seeing Samuel caused the woman to recognize Saul". All of these readings agree that the chapter condemns what Saul did, and 1 Chronicles 10:13-14 names consulting a medium among the reasons Saul died.

Sources and Licensing

This guide uses the historical-grammatical method of interpretation, considering each passage in its historical, literary, and biblical context.

  • Berean Standard Bible

    Berean Bible. Scripture text of the key verses printed in each session, and translation footnotes. Public domain.

  • Tyndale Open Study Notes, 1 Samuel

    Tyndale House Publishers. Book introduction and verse notes on 1 Samuel, quoted verbatim and located by the verses each note comments on. CC BY-SA 4.0.

  • Protos study guide editorial

    Protos. Outline, session divisions, questions, leader notes and summaries of where Christians read 1 Samuel differently. CC BY-SA 4.0.

Scripture quotations are from the Berean Standard Bible (BSB), public domain. Quotations from the Tyndale Open Study Notes are verbatim, located by the verses each note comments on, and shared under CC BY-SA 4.0.

Edition 2026.2. This guide is licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0. You may copy, print, adapt, and share it with attribution under the same license.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main themes of 1 Samuel?

1 Samuel tells how Israel moved from judges to kings, and it asks what kind of king God's people need. A barren woman's prayer brings Samuel, who speaks the LORD's word to a nation that had stopped hearing it. The people ask for a king like the other nations have, and God gives them Saul, who looks the part and does not obey. God then chooses David, the youngest son, and David waits for the throne instead of taking it. Hannah's prayer states the theme at the start: the LORD humbles and exalts, and he will exalt the horn of his anointed (2:7-10).

How should I study 1 Samuel?

Read 1 Samuel as a story told by a narrator who seldom stops to comment. When he does ("the LORD was with him", 3:19; 18:14), take note, because those lines tell you how to weigh what you see. Much is reported without approval: David lies (21:2; 27:10) and Saul consults a medium (28:7), and the narrator lets the results speak. Follow the pairs the book sets side by side: Hannah and Peninnah, Samuel and Eli's sons, Saul and Jonathan, Saul and David.

Is this 1 Samuel study guide free?

Yes. Read it online, download the PDF, or print a copy. No account, email, or purchase is required.

How long does this 1 Samuel study take?

The guide includes 12 sequential sessions. The book overview can be used for one 30 to 45 minute meeting.

Can a church use this guide?

Yes. You may print, share, and adapt it with attribution under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license.

Read it in context

Study 1 Samuel with Protos

Read the Bible with verse-by-verse commentary, historical background, and original-language study tools.

The Protos reader open on Genesis 1 with the How to Read Genesis background sheet raised over it

Testimonies from pastors and Bible teachers

“Great app for diving into Scripture wherever you are. It makes it easy and convenient to study on the go.”
Pastor Darren Raynald
5 out of 5 stars

Pastor Darren Raynald

Pastor, MountainHouse ChurchTeaches at Portland Bible College

“Been using Protos for months now. Protos is an amazing Bible study app for anyone who wants to grow deeper in God's Word. I love how it helps me understand Scripture beyond simply reading the verses, providing helpful historical context, commentary, and insights into the original Hebrew and Greek. The resources make it easier to engage with the Bible and grow in understanding.”
Pastor Jason Layantara
5 out of 5 stars

Pastor Jason Layantara

Teaching Pastor, MountainHouse ChurchM.A. in Christian Leadership · Bible class teacher, Lake Tahoe

"People often think they have a discipline problem because they struggle to read the Bible for more than a few minutes, while they can watch movies for hours. It may not be an attention-span problem so much as an immersion problem: when you understand the story, the people, the world, and what is happening, two hours can disappear. But when you do not understand what you are reading, even ten minutes can feel like work. So you skim past the words and jump straight to what the passage means for you before you have listened to what God is saying through the text, the story, and the voice of the writer. It happens so often that theology has a name for it: eisegesis."
Fabio JonathanFabio JonathanFounder of Protos · Portland Bible College graduate

Protos helps you close that gap so you can stop skimming and start getting immersed in the world of the Bible.

★★★★★4.8 from 121 App Store ratings

The streak feature actually got people in my congregation excited to read, especially the youth. We've started comparing notes after service.
5 out of 5 starsPhilPastor, Ohio
between work + kids i barely get time to breathe lol. but protos somehow helps making deep studies doable. i've been reading during lunch breaks again for the first time in years.
5 out of 5 starsCalebA dad
been using protos for like 2 weeks now. It helps me prep for our small group without getting overwhelmed. The context snippets show up right where I need them.
5 out of 5 starsChloe ChuaSmall group leader, Singapore

Start understanding the Bible better.

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play